Three kinds of
'smartphone free'
School smartphone policies come in many varieties. Restrictive policies generally fit into the three categories below. These categories have been developed by Headteachers. For further detail, see the FAQs.
Please note: smartphones are distinct from simple phones ('brick' phones) in this policy rating. Many gold rated schools allow simple phones on site, whilst banning smartphones. Simple phones may be handled with a different set of rules, such as 'no see, no hear' or 'locked away, or confiscation periods may differ depending on the type of phone, for example.

Gold level
No smartphones on site (different rules may apply to simple 'brick' phones)
Gold standard smartphone free schools don't allow pupils to bring smartphones on to the school site. Research has shown that this is an "Effective Policy", which improves behaviour and sees a rise in academic attainment*.
The added benefit of a Gold rating is that children do not collect a smartphone towards the end of the school day, so smartphones are not used on the commute. This reduces safeguarding risks associated with children showing each other content on smartphones, reduces peer pressure to own one, and according to the MET police, reduces the risk of mugging.
'Simple' phones (also known as 'brick' phones) may have different rules. Gold standard smartphone free schools often allow simple phones to be brought to school; these may be treated with a 'no see no hear' policy or a 'locked away' policy. Simple phones sometimes have shorter confiscation periods if used. Under the gold rating, it is specifically smartphones that are not allowed on site.

Silver level
Smartphones are handed in or locked away.
Silver standard smartphone free schools ensure that smartphones are inaccessible to students during the school day.
Schools handle this in various ways. The most cost effective and fail-safe ways to manage phone storage are through collective storage, such as:
- a central locker for groups of phones
- handing phones in to a box in a form room
- in primary schools, it is common to hand phones into reception.
The above central storage systems mean that the phone is not carried on the child's person, meaning that hot-spotting or breaking into personal storage cases are not an option.
The silver rating provides a reasonably distraction free school day (apart from the above possibilities), helping students to focus and socialise. However, other disadvantages include:
- children can still collect a smartphone at the end of the day for the commute or after school clubs. This can expose both the child and their surrounding peers to the risks inherent to smartphones, including:
- exposure to inappropriate content
- increased risks of muggings
- increased risks of road accidents
- opportunity cost where chilldren are not socialising with peers, etc.

Bronze level
Smartphones are never used, but stay with pupil
Bronze standard smartphone free schools do not allow children to use their smartphone during the school day, though they may keep possession of it. Bronze is a big step for many schools, and teachers report seeing benefits, such as fewer confiscations and sightings with smartphones. There is also found to be a reduction in bullying compared with more permissive policies.*
However, Bronze level schools don't see such significant benefits that the silver and gold schools enjoy.
Department for Education categories
The 'Gold', 'Silver' and 'Bronze' categories of smartphone free schools were originally designed with the Department for Education’s ‘Guidance for schools on prohibiting the use of mobile phones throughout the school day’. We are reviewing the categories in the light of updated guidance.
We have added one simple clarification, which is that 'simple' or 'brick' phone policies are not categorised as part of this scheme. Whether simple phones are handed in, switched off in bags, or used at any time, it's not reflected in this listing.
63%
of secondary schools have a smartphone free policy that applies throughout the day (Gold, Silver or Bronze)*
11%
of secondary schools have an "effective ban", leading to improved attainment (Gold or Silver)*
83%
of parents believe that smartphones are harmful to children*
